The DA won Gauteng’s metros. It may govern none of them
The DA won the most seats in Johannesburg, Tshwane and Ekurhuleni on 4 November. Two weeks later it may govern none of them.
ActionSA leader Herman Mashaba has confirmed progress towards a possible coalition agreement with the ANC across Gauteng’s three big metros, IOL reports. No deal has been signed. But the direction of travel is now plain, and Johannesburg and Tshwane are expected to hold their first council sittings this Thursday, 19 November.
The deal on the table
According to the Sunday Times, ANC provincial and regional leaders are pushing for an ANC-ActionSA arrangement across the metros. ActionSA’s preferred version, as described by insiders, would make Mashaba mayor of Johannesburg, keep Nasiphi Moya as mayor of Tshwane and leave Ekurhuleni to the ANC. ActionSA has not confirmed that split publicly.
“I think we could have the buy-in of the EFF, MK Party and all the smaller parties,” an ActionSA insider told the paper.
That last part matters, because the ANC and ActionSA cannot do this alone.
The seat maths
On the final seat counts compiled by Reported from IEC results, the ANC and ActionSA together fall short in all three metros. In Johannesburg they hold 106 of 270 seats, 30 short of a majority. In Tshwane they have 92 of 214, 16 short. In Ekurhuleni they have 99 of 224, 14 short.
Add the EFF and the MK Party and the picture changes. The Detail puts the four-party bloc at 138 of 270 in Johannesburg against a threshold of 136, 109 of 214 in Tshwane against 108, and 128 of 224 in Ekurhuleni against 113.
Read that again. In Tshwane, the capital, a government would rest on one seat. In Johannesburg, on two. One absent councillor, one defection, one sulking small party, and the mayor is gone.
Why the DA is on the outside
The DA is the largest single party in all three councils, with 91 seats in Johannesburg, 74 in Tshwane and 66 in Ekurhuleni, according to The Detail. Being largest is not the same as being able to govern.
Mashaba did offer the DA a route in. In a letter to DA leader Geordin Hill-Lewis dated 7 November, reported by Daily Maverick, he proposed that both he and Helen Zille step back as Johannesburg mayoral candidates, with the DA naming someone else and ActionSA taking the deputy mayoralty. In Tshwane, he asked that Cilliers Brink give up his council seat and that the DA back Moya.
Those are hard terms for a party that topped the poll: drop your mayoral candidate in Johannesburg, and drop your former mayor in Tshwane. Whether the DA thought they were worth paying is a question its voters will want answered.
Patriotic Alliance leader Gayton McKenzie has gone further, predicting an ANC, ActionSA, EFF and MK arrangement and arguing, per IOL, that keeping the DA out of the metros would weaken its bargaining power inside the Government of National Unity. That is a prediction, not a confirmed deal. But it names the stakes honestly. These councils are being traded as national chips.
What residents should watch
Johannesburg and Tshwane residents have lived through this before: mayors elected with thin margins, motions of no confidence, budgets stalled while councillors count heads. The last term gave both cities a front-row seat to how fragile one-seat majorities are.
The Detail notes that calls have been made for coalition agreements to be put in writing and made public. That is the minimum. If four parties are going to share Johannesburg’s budget, residents should be able to read what each of them was promised.
Three questions for Thursday:
- Does any bloc arrive with a signed, published agreement, or only a handshake?
- Who gets the finance and infrastructure portfolios, the ones that decide whether water and power actually work?
- What stops the next motion of no confidence, given a one-seat margin in Tshwane?
Councils have until 26 November to be constituted, Reported notes, citing IOL. Whoever wins the vote this week inherits cities that need stability more than they need clever arithmetic.
Qwezzy
