A 4-3 hold, a R17.45 rand: why your bond is safe only until January
Your home loan repayment will not go up this month. That is the good news from the Reserve Bank. The less comfortable news is how close it came, and what the markets did on the same afternoon.
On Thursday the Monetary Policy Committee kept the repo rate at 7.25%, which leaves prime at 10.75%. But the vote was four to three. Three of the seven members wanted another 25 basis point hike, according to the Reserve Bank’s own statement. That is the narrowest possible hold, and it came after two increases this year, in May and September.
Why the bank is nervous
Governor Lesetja Kganyago’s statement is unusually blunt about where the pain is coming from. Fuel inflation is around 40%. Petrol is “almost R30 a litre now, up from R21 a year ago”. More than a third of all inflation in the country is coming from transport. October CPI, published a day before the decision, was 5.2%, up from 4.5% in September and well above the bank’s 3% target.
The bank expects inflation above 5% to persist into early next year. It now only sees inflation back at 3% in the third quarter of 2028, later than it previously expected, Business Day reports. And it flags new pressure on food: “Food inflation is bottoming out from current lows,” the statement says, with El Niño and dry conditions early next year a risk to harvests. Water restrictions in the Western Cape get a specific mention.
The committee assessed the risks to inflation as being to the upside, and said it “will not hesitate to raise rates if needed”.
The scenarios are the real warning
The most useful part of the statement is the scenarios. In one, oil peaks at $130 a barrel and refinery margins stay high. Headline inflation stays above 5% next year, growth sits at about 1%, and the policy rate rises by around two more hikes. In the second, global bond yields rise and investors demand a bigger risk premium from countries like South Africa, with a weaker rand. The result is similar: higher inflation, lower growth, and at least two hikes.
Read that second scenario against what happened in the markets on the same day.
The rand did not wait
The rand closed Thursday at R17.45 to the dollar, its weakest close since 4 November last year, Business Day reports. It has lost 4.4% this month. The JSE all share closed at its lowest level since September last year, after a 3.66% fall on Wednesday. The 10-year government bond yield touched 8.975%, its highest since early October.
Much of that is global. A stronger dollar, expectations of further US rate hikes, and gold down about 30% since late February all hurt. But analysts quoted by Business Day also point at home. Stanlib’s Victor Mphaphuli said the market was worried about what the Gauteng coalition talks, which look set to shut out the DA, mean for the government of national unity.
The ANC’s answer, quoted by Bloomberg via Polity, was that “financial markets have no right to dictate those negotiations”. That is true as a matter of democracy. It is also irrelevant to what a weaker rand does to the price of fuel, imported medicine and food. Markets do not get a vote, but they do set the exchange rate that every household pays.
Investec’s Annabel Bishop made the more useful point: the market’s best outcome is not a particular combination of parties, but “stable coalitions that endure through budget cycles”.
What it means for December
Motorists were promised some relief. Mid-month Central Energy Fund data pointed to petrol falling by about R2.65 a litre for 93 and R2.90 for 95 inland in December, Sowetan reported, while 500ppm diesel could rise. Those estimates used data up to 16 November, when the rand was near R17 to the dollar. A rand at R17.45 eats into that over-recovery, and part of the fuel tax relief is also being reversed. The official adjustment takes effect on 2 December.
For borrowers, the next MPC decision is on 28 January. With three members already voting to hike, a weaker rand, and the bank’s own scenarios pointing to two more increases if things go wrong, nobody should plan their 2027 budget around a rate cut. The bank’s projection model still shows lower rates next year, but the bank itself calls that “a broad policy guide”.
The accountability question
The Reserve Bank has said what it will do if inflation does not ease. The political class owes the same clarity. Coalition partners in Gauteng have until 27 November to put governments in place. Whatever they agree, the cost of a messy, unstable deal will not be paid in Luthuli House or in Sandton boardrooms. It will be paid at the pump, at the till and on the bond repayment, by people who voted for working cities.
