Swapping councillors, swapping mayors: what the Gauteng bidding war says about voters
Two weeks after the 4 November local government elections, the fight for Gauteng’s three metros has turned into an auction, and ActionSA is the one holding the hammer. What is being offered tells you a lot about how parties think about the people who voted.
The ANC is expected to brief the media on its coalition talks today, EWN reports, ahead of Thursday’s first council sittings in Johannesburg and Tshwane.
The ANC offer, and the list swap
Business Day reports that the ANC has sent ActionSA a proposal that would make Herman Mashaba mayor of Johannesburg, keep Nasiphi Moya as mayor of Tshwane, and hand Ekurhuleni to the ANC. ActionSA spokesperson Matthew George confirmed the party had received correspondence from both the ANC and the DA.
The more striking detail is in the Sunday Times. A senior ANC leader told the paper that ActionSA had proposed amending its own proportional representation lists in all three metros to make room for ANC candidates who failed to win council seats. In Johannesburg, the leader said, ActionSA would remove one of its councillors and add Loyiso Masuku so she could become deputy mayor. Similar space would be made in Tshwane and Ekurhuleni.
ActionSA has not confirmed this publicly, and it is one insider’s account. But if accurate, it should make voters uncomfortable. People who voted ActionSA on the PR ballot voted for ActionSA’s list. Under this plan, a seat they gave ActionSA would be used to seat an ANC politician the ANC’s own voters did not return. That may be legal, since parties control their lists. It is still a deal made over voters’ heads.
“How can we say no to that?” the ANC leader asked. That is the problem in one line: the offer was designed to be irresistible to party structures, not to residents.
The DA’s counter
The DA is not standing still. The Sunday Times reports that federal leader Geordin Hill-Lewis has floated swapping roles with Helen Zille, moving from the Cape Town mayoralty to Johannesburg while Zille returns to the Western Cape. Insiders also say Hill-Lewis has conceded ActionSA’s demand that Cilliers Brink step aside in Tshwane for Moya.
Hill-Lewis would not confirm or deny it. “We don’t negotiate in the media. All options are on the table,” he told the paper.
Consider what that means for Cape Town. Residents there elected a DA council and a mayor who is about to manage Level 1 water restrictions and a hot, dry summer. They may now get a different mayor because of a negotiation in another province. Again, parties are entitled to deploy their people. But the logic is the same as the list swap: positions as bargaining chips.
The numbers behind the leverage
Business Day’s figures from the final results show why ActionSA can name its price. In Johannesburg, the DA took 34.79%, the ANC 20.25% and ActionSA 16.27%. In Tshwane, the DA had 34.37%, ActionSA 22.07% and the ANC 20.22%. In Ekurhuleni, the DA won 30.68%, the ANC 22.11% and ActionSA 18.5%.
The DA was the largest party in all three and may govern none. The ANC was second or third and may govern all three, directly or through a partner. Mashaba has been blunt about his calculation. “If ActionSA goes to bed with the DA, there won’t be ActionSA in 2029,” he posted on 16 November, quoted by Business Day.
Daily Maverick reports that Johannesburg remains the sticking point, with the ANC backing Masuku and Mashaba wanting the chain, and that any ANC-ActionSA pact still needs smaller parties to reach a majority. That makes whatever emerges on Thursday potentially fragile.
The question for Thursday
None of this is unusual in coalition politics, and voters chose fragmentation. But fragmentation is not consent for anything. When councils sit, residents should ask three things of whoever forms the government: what written agreement binds the partners, who exactly was placed on which list and why, and what happens to service delivery if the arrangement collapses in six months.
Johannesburg and Tshwane have been here before. The parties at the table have had a full term to learn what unstable coalitions cost. This week will show whether they did.
