Tshwane wants you to save water. Its own tariff may pay the biggest users to waste it
Tshwane moved to Level 2 water restrictions on Monday, 16 November. The message to residents is simple: use less, or pay more. The problem is that the city’s own approved tariff may say the opposite to the people who use the most.
According to Moneyweb, the gazetted Level 2 tariff for consumers using more than 60 kilolitres a month is R16.63 per kilolitre. The normal tariff for that same block is R64.26. If that figure stands, the heaviest water users in the city would be paying roughly a quarter of what they normally pay, during restrictions that exist precisely to make heavy use more expensive.
What Tshwane has actually imposed
City spokesperson Lindela Mashigo told EWN the restrictions came after a directive from Cogta and from Rand Water that consumption was too high. Under Level 2, watering gardens is banned between 9am and 5.30pm, and cars may only be washed with hosepipes fitted with self-closing devices. Borehole users are exempt but must put up visible signage.
Moneyweb reports that Tshwane has recorded week-on-week high consumption at its Rand Water supply meters since September, running 34% above its permanent licence target and 19% above its temporary target. The metro has been asked to cut use by 200 megalitres a day. Ordinary households are now limited to 20 kilolitres a month, and the city says metro police and bylaw officials will run random inspections in high-use areas, with fines starting at R5,000 and possible criminal prosecution.
So the stick is real for households. The question is whether it applies at the top.
The disappearing number
The way the city communicated this is part of the story. Moneyweb lays out the sequence: the restrictions were announced on Sunday evening, 15 November. On Monday morning the statement was pulled and replaced with the same document stamped “Postponed” in red. That evening a new version appeared with a tariff table, except that the line for users above 60 kilolitres no longer showed a number. It simply read “Applicable approved tariff”. On Tuesday the city confirmed Level 2 had in fact been in force since 16 November and acknowledged that the postponement notice may have caused confusion.
A businessman who checks his tariffs against the provincial gazette spotted the R16.63 figure and told Moneyweb his theory: the intended number was R166.30, and a decimal point went astray. That is a plausible explanation. It is not yet an official one. The City of Tshwane declined to comment to Moneyweb.
Who signed this off
This is where a typo becomes an accountability question. Moneyweb understands the figure was carried through the metro’s budget process, including public participation, and approved by the full council. Provincial and national treasuries also approved the tariff structure.
That is a lot of checkpoints for a number that, on its face, rewards the biggest consumers during a water crisis. Either nobody read the top block closely, or someone did and the error was quietly managed by leaving the number out of later statements. Residents deserve to know which.
The fix is not simple either. A tariff approved by council and gazetted cannot just be changed in a press release. Until it is corrected, the city faces a choice between charging the gazetted rate or charging a rate that has no legal standing.
Cape Town is acting earlier
The contrast with Cape Town is useful. The City of Cape Town says Level 1 restrictions start on 1 December, with a guide of 85 litres per person per day and garden watering limited to one hour on Tuesdays and Saturdays, before 9am or after 6pm. Dam levels stood at 70.4% on 16 November, 13.4 percentage points lower than a year ago, and daily use had hit 951 million litres against a target of 860 million.
That followed Water and Sanitation Minister Pemmy Majodina’s announcement, reported by SAnews, of a 7% cut in domestic and industrial allocations and a 15% cut for irrigation from the Western Cape Water Supply System, with forecasts pointing to a strong to extreme El Niño.
Cape Town’s own officials frame this as acting before dams are critically low. Tshwane is acting under instruction from Rand Water after months of overuse, and with a tariff schedule it apparently cannot publish in full.
What to watch
Tshwane is also in the middle of a change of government, with its new council expected to sit this week. Whoever takes the mayoral chain inherits this. The first test is easy to state: publish the correct tariff for the top block, explain how R16.63 got through council and two treasuries, and say what the biggest users will actually be billed in November.
Households on a 20 kilolitre cap are being told to expect inspections and R5,000 fines. The least the city owes them is proof that the same rules bite at the top.
