ActionSA gets the mayoral chains. The ANC wants the purse.
If the Gauteng deal lands the way the paperwork describes it, Herman Mashaba will wear Johannesburg’s mayoral chain from next week. The ANC will hold the chequebook. Residents who voted for change in Soweto, Tembisa and Atteridgeville should read the fine print before they celebrate or despair.
A letter from ANC secretary-general Fikile Mbalula to ActionSA chairperson Michael Beaumont, dated 18 November and reported by TimesLIVE this morning, formally accepts ActionSA’s proposal to take the executive mayoralties of Johannesburg and Tshwane. The price is spelt out in one sentence: “Wherever the ANC enters a government alongside ActionSA, whether or not it holds the chain of office, the ANC takes the Speaker’s chair and the finance portfolio.”
What each side gets
In Johannesburg, the ANC’s proposal gives ActionSA the mayoralty plus public safety, corporate and shared services, and economic development and planning. The ANC wants the deputy mayor’s office, the Speaker, finance, water and environment, roads and transport, and human settlements. It also wants to chair the Municipal Public Accounts Committee (MPAC), the body that is meant to scrutinise how the city spends its money.
In Tshwane, the shape is similar. ActionSA keeps Nasiphi Moya as mayor and takes utilities and public safety. The ANC takes a deputy mayor who carries finance, the Speaker, roads and transport, and human settlements, and again wants the MPAC chair. In Ekurhuleni, the ANC wants the mayor, Speaker, finance and a new deputy mayor.
The deal is not signed, and the versions do not match
Beaumont told TimesLIVE that nothing has been finalised. IOL reports an unsigned structure in which the MK Party, not the ANC, gets Joburg’s deputy mayoralty, with the EFF as deputy in Tshwane and ActionSA as deputy in Ekurhuleni. Mbalula’s letter claims the deputy posts for the ANC. Both cannot be true, and that gap is exactly where coalitions in this province have broken before.
According to the Mail & Guardian, more than 10 parties met at the Emoyeni Conference Centre in Parktown on Thursday, with Gauteng premier Panyaza Lesufi in the chair. Mashaba told the paper that negotiations had effectively concluded, with only positions and governing rules outstanding, and that he wanted to sign “today or tomorrow”. Johannesburg’s council, per IOL, sits on Monday. Tshwane sits on 26 November, and every council must sit by 27 November.
The arithmetic is thin
The Mail & Guardian’s numbers: the ANC, ActionSA, EFF and MK hold 138 of 270 seats in Johannesburg, two more than the 136 needed. In Tshwane they have 109 of 214, one more than the 108 needed. Ekurhuleni is more comfortable at 128 of 224. Mbalula’s own letter concedes the margins are “uncomfortably narrow” and says the ANC’s national executive committee will discuss widening the coalitions.
Johannesburg has had seven mayors since 2021. A two-seat majority built from four parties, with deputy posts still in dispute, is not a stability plan. It is a starting position.
Where the real power sits
A mayor can set direction, but the finance portfolio shapes the budget, and the Speaker runs the council chamber, including when and how motions of no confidence are handled. MPAC is the oversight body. Under the ANC’s proposal it would hold all three in Johannesburg and Tshwane, while the mayor’s party gets the public face of service delivery.
There is a small concession in the other direction. Mbalula accepted ActionSA’s principle that section 79 committee chairs should come from a different party from the mayoral committee member they oversee, calling it “a sound check”. That is a good rule. It sits awkwardly next to the ANC claiming the main oversight chair for itself in metros where it does not hold the mayoralty.
The letter also records three disagreements. The ANC rejects a rule that would withdraw reports from council whenever a partner disputes them, warning it would hand partners a veto over the budget, which it says is incompatible with the Municipal Finance Management Act. It rejects unanimous sign-off on motions, and it declines ActionSA’s proposal for illegal immigration units in metro police, saying immigration enforcement is a national competence under the Immigration Act.
The DA question
The DA won the most votes in all three metros, 34.79% in Johannesburg, 34.37% in Tshwane and 30.68% in Ekurhuleni, according to the M&G, and is now on the outside. Mashaba told the paper that talks with the DA failed because the party would not drop Helen Zille and Cilliers Brink. “They wasted a week and a half, and the train has moved,” he said.
DA leader Geordin Hill-Lewis told Bloomberg, via Polity, that leaving the national unity government “isn’t ever off the table”, although the GNU is not the current focus. The rand closed Thursday at its weakest level in more than a year.
What to watch
Before Monday: is the deal signed and published, not just briefed? Who actually holds the deputy mayor posts? Does ActionSA accept the ANC holding finance, the Speaker and MPAC in metros ActionSA would lead? And will the parties tell residents, in writing, how disputes get settled without collapsing the council?
Voters in Gauteng were promised a clean break. On the current paperwork, they get a new mayor and the same hands on the money. If ActionSA can show that its “sound check” rules have teeth, that might be enough. If not, the count of Johannesburg mayors since 2021 will keep climbing.
